Caterinas Pizzeria: Authentic NYC Pizza Experience in Brooklyn
Caterinas Pizzeria, located at 907 Livonia Ave in Brooklyn, NY, is a beloved culinary gem that captures the essence of classic New York pizza. Known for its exceptional Pepperoni slices, the pizzeria delights customers with its fresh-from-the-oven pies and warm, nostalgic atmosphere. Many patrons express their affection for Caterinas through heartfelt reviews, reminiscing about memorable flavors and the welcoming service reminiscent of childhood visits. The pizzeria has a loyal following, with long-time customers cherishing both the delectable dishes and the community spirit fostered by familiar faces. Dive into Caterinas for a taste of pizza perfection that never disappoints.
Photos & Gallery
Caterinas Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Just as expected!..Excellent NYC slice of Pepperoni pizza with a mango mandarin orange Snapple
I smelt Caterinas Pizza when I got off the bus gotta have "TWO SLICES " you know like Radio Raheem didnt have the boombox or attitude waited for the first pie fresh from oven its served in the box I opt for paper plates got'em flip the parch paper with slices one on top of other toss the box out position,g the hot girls bite it hot hot hot ok it's good no condiments needed finished them by Stan lee Ave next time I'm sampling spett/mballs CIAO
I have never ordered anything that I did not enjoy eating and the customer service is amazing. It's like the old times going to your favorite pizzeria.
I remember Eddie back in the days when I was a NYPD Police Officer as a rookie on a foot post I was always hanging out in the back of this pizzeria . Ed was the best. If you get to see this Ed just wanted to say hello my good friend hope all is well from your buddy Police Officer Ortiz 075 pct. Now living in Florida. Stay bless brother.
I love this place. I've been going here for years.
Love the pizza. Neighborhood staple and loyal customers. Always great pizza and welcoming.
Location
-
907 Livonia Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, United States Hotline: +1 718-385-5305
Welcome to Caterinas Pizzeria, a true gem nestled at 907 Livonia Ave in Brooklyn, NY. Known among locals for its authentic New York-style pizza, this pizzeria invites all pizza lovers to indulge in its rich culinary offerings. With a dedicated following, Caterinas is celebrated for its mouthwatering slices and warm, inviting atmosphere.
As you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough and melting cheese envelops you, setting the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Customers rave about the pepperoni pizza, described as an “excellent NYC slice,” showcasing a perfect balance of crispy crust, savory sauce, and generous toppings. Zoraida Velez’s fondness for the classic combination of pepperoni pizza paired with a refreshing mango mandarin Snapple exemplifies the simple yet delightful pleasures that Caterinas serves.
But it’s not just the food that makes Caterinas a standout. The warmth of the service is an integral part of the experience. Regulars like Elaine Kimbrough consistently highlight the impeccable customer service, evoking a nostalgic feel reminiscent of the good old days spent at their favorite pizzeria. This hospitable environment ensures that every visit feels like a reunion with family.
Stories of camaraderie and nostalgia abound among patrons. As Lewis Ortiz recalls, his past visits as a rookie NYPD officer were filled with camaraderie and connection with the staff, particularly with Ed, one of the beloved figures at the pizzeria. It's this shared history that adds to the charm and character of Caterinas. Visitors often find themselves returning not just for the incredible food but to share their own stories and make new memories.
Overall, Caterinas Pizzeria embodies the essence of New York pizza culture. Whether indulging in a hot slice on a paper plate or savoring classic Italian dishes like spaghetti and meatballs, every bite is a taste of tradition. For locals and visitors alike, it offers the perfect place to unwind and enjoy great food in the heart of Brooklyn.
For inquiries or to place your order, you can reach them at +1 718-385-5305. Don’t miss out on this iconic pizzeria that feels like home.
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Service options
- Kerbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards